Jump to content
Evolution Fairytale Forum
Sign in to follow this  
Ron

A Few Questions For The Atheists

Recommended Posts

I have a few questions for the atheists. But before I ask, I will make the following stipulations for the discussion within this thread, to keep the fluff out of this thread:

 

1- No equivocations on the questions, or to the questions!

2- No time wasting or side tracking to divert from the questions (i.e. tangents, or rabbit trails).

3- If you don't know, simply say "I don't know"! But, understand, in saying so, you give up all right to say (for example) "there is no God"; because you said "I don't know". This includes making statements like (for example) "there is no evidence for God, therefore there is no God" because; you said "I don't know". If you do attempt such, you are equivocating.

4- If you are going to make a "Negative" assertion without factual evidence for said assertion, you are equivocating.

5- If you are going to make any assertions to support your argument, insure they are factual assertions, not simply opinion. Otherwise you are equivocating.

6- Any assertions that do not deal directly with the questions are either equivocating or time wasting.

7- If you post links to other people's opinions (regardless of their scholarship) without factual supporting evidences for said opinion, you are equivocating (and so were they).

 

SO…. If, according to the atheist, we go to nothing when we die; from where did we come, to get here?

 

We have existence right now… We can prove "said existence" inductively, by (but not limited to):

1- Interacting with each other both physically and intellectually.

2- Interacting with the world both physically and intellectually.

 

We've had existence in the past… We can prove "said existence" inductively, by (but not limited to):

1- Reading the historical documentation left to us from the authors of said antiquities (i.e. recorded data) interacting with each other both physically and intellectually.

2- Researching the archeological evidences left to us from the lives of those who lived in antiquity.

3- Reconciling the evidences of historical documentation and archeological evidences to test and validate each.

 

Therefore, we know for a fact, using the empirical scientific method, that we have (and have had) existence. This existence is substantive, and yet there are metaphysical and ethereal aspects to our existence that we use to drive the rational of said existence (Thoughts, the "Laws of Logic", altruistic Love, the "Laws of Mathematics" etc… to name a few). Because we are here, we know we came from somewhere because there is absolutely no evidence of something coming from nothing.

 

Questions: From where did we come (what are our Origins)? What are the atheistic foundations to support the atheistic worldview and philosophy of our origins?

 

 

<edited by Ron 01/01/2010> any repetitive equivocations, and/or repetitive equivocating statements will be removed to keep the fluff down, and hopefully, meaningful conversation flowing.

 

<edited by Ron 12/20/2011>This post was in need of additionall editing due to the false assertions of digitalartist claiming the words "FACT/FACTUAL" were not contained (required) in the OP. Therefore said words were highlighted in red, emboldened AND underlined, so-as-to relieve that blatant lie from being used in the future to keep the equivocations down, and hopefully, meaningful conversation flowing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

SO…. If, according to the atheist, we go to nothing when we die; from where did we come, to get here?

47396[/snapback]

Atheism makes no claims about life before birth or after death.

 

But to answer your question it's the same place I think. Before I was born I didn't exist, and after I die I wont exist. In both cases, I simply wont be.

 

From where did we come (what are our Origins)?

47396[/snapback]

Well you already know the scientific answer to that question, that we share a common ancestor with other similar apes.

 

To put it another way, we all came from a union between our parents, who were a little different from their parents, who were a little different from their parents, and so on and so forth.

 

What are the atheistic foundations to support the atheistic worldview and philosophy of our origins?

47396[/snapback]

The foundation of an atheistic world view is no belief in any god. Atheism doesn't have anything to say on origins.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Atheism makes no claims about life before birth or after death.

47398[/snapback]

Did you say this with a straight face? :huh:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Did you say this with a straight face? :huh:

47400[/snapback]

Not only that, but he totally ignored the equivocation stipulations posted :lol:

 

Unfortunately, I don't have time to respond right now. I just returned from my long drive from Johnstown, and the wife and I are going to spend New Years with her family.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest martemius

Questions: From where did we come (what are our Origins)?

47396[/snapback]

By that question are you referring to origins on a cosmic scale (the big bang) or origins on a human level (abiogenesis)?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

By that question are you referring to origins on a cosmic scale (the big bang) or origins on a human level (abiogenesis)?

47409[/snapback]

Well, can't we have both? :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

By that question are you referring to origins on a cosmic scale (the big bang) or origins on a human level (abiogenesis)?

47409[/snapback]

I thought he was referring to us as individuals with the first questions, and as a species with the second. Then he went on to ask about the foundations of an atheists world view.

 

He didn't exactly make himself clear did he? I'm starting to recognise this as a standard tactic. He leaves himself vague and when he doesn't get the answer he wants, BAM, he hits you with the equivocation trump card.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Atheism makes no claims about life before birth or after death.

47398[/snapback]

Then why do you totally refute this statement in your third sentence? Further, by making such a statement, you are admitting that atheism has no foundation. So, in essence, you are saying “I don’t knowâ€ÂÂ, and any other comments are equivocation.

 

 

But to answer your question it's the same place I think. 

47398[/snapback]

This is neither an answer, nor is it a cogent statement. It’s an unsupported statement attempting to support another statement (that, itself, refutes one of your later statements) that it-self has no evidentiary support. And, both statements it is attempting to tie together are equivocations as per #’s 3, 4 and 5

 

Before I was born I didn't exist, and after I die I wont exist. 

47398[/snapback]

This is an equivocation as per #4 and #5, in which case you should fall back on the first sentence in #3.

 

In both cases, I simply wont be.

47398[/snapback]

This is an equivocation as per #4, in which case you should fall back on the first sentence in #3.

 

Well you already know the scientific answer to that question, that we share a common ancestor with other similar apes.

47398[/snapback]

This is not only an equivocation as per #2 and #5, but per the Forum rules as well (See Macro-evolution)

 

To put it another way, we all came from a union between our parents, who were a little different from their parents, who were a little different from their parents, and so on and so forth.

47398[/snapback]

This is not an answer because it doesn’t address the question. It has nothing to do with foundations, but more to do with the present. This can also be considered equivocation as per #2.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The foundation of an atheistic world view is no belief in any god. 

47398[/snapback]

This is not an answer to the questions asked, it is simply a statement. It provides no evidence for any foundational substance, it is simply fluff.

 

Atheism doesn't have anything to say on origins.

47398[/snapback]

This is, in essence, a parroting of your first sentence. It has no intrinsic value to the conversation because it doesn’t answer either of the questions I asked, and it doesn’t provide any evidentiary support for atheistic foundations. In other words, it is fluff (in the context of the questions asked), and it is equivocation as per #2 and #6.

 

So, to get you back on track, and have a meaningful conversation, I will reiterate:

 

SO…. If, according to the atheist, we go to nothing when we die; from where did we come, to get here?

 

We have existence right now… We can prove “said existence†inductively, by (but not limited to):

1- Interacting with each other both physically and intellectually.

2- Interacting with the world both physically and intellectually.

 

We’ve had existence in the past… We can prove “said existence†inductively, by (but not limited to):

1- Reading the historical documentation left to us from the authors of said antiquities (i.e. recorded data) interacting with each other both physically and intellectually.

2- Researching the archeological evidences left to us from the lives of those who lived in antiquity.

3- Reconciling the evidences of historical documentation and archeological evidences to test and validate each.

 

Therefore, we know for a fact, using the empirical scientific method, that we have (and have had) existence. This existence is substantive, and yet there are metaphysical and ethereal aspects to our existence that we use to drive the rational of said existence (Thoughts, the “Laws of Logicâ€ÂÂ, altruistic Love, the “Laws of Mathematics†etc… to name a few). Because we are here, we know we came from somewhere because there is absolutely no evidence of something coming from nothing.

 

Questions: From where did we come (what are our Origins)? What are the atheistic foundations to support the atheistic worldview and philosophy of our origins?

47396[/snapback]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

By that question are you referring to origins on a cosmic scale (the big bang) or origins on a human level (abiogenesis)?

47409[/snapback]

Its fairly simple martemius, I made it that way on purpose.

 

From where did we come (what are our Origins)? What are the atheistic foundations to support the atheistic worldview and philosophy of our origins?

47396[/snapback]

We know we “areâ€ÂÂ! We know “from nothing, nothing comesâ€ÂÂ… SO:

 

From where did we come (what are our Origins)?

47396[/snapback]

AND

 

What are the atheistic foundations to support the atheistic worldview and philosophy of our origins?

47396[/snapback]

 

 

 

Also, remember... No equivocating!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I thought he was referring to us as individuals with the first questions, and as a species with the second.  Then he went on to ask about the foundations of an atheists world view.

 

He didn't exactly make himself clear did he?  I'm starting to recognise this as a standard tactic.  He leaves himself vague and when he doesn't get the answer he wants, BAM, he hits you with the equivocation trump card.

47426[/snapback]

I made myself crystal clear. And I’m leaving you (and by you I mean the equivocator, not you personally… Unless you attempt to equivocate) absolutely no wiggle room (as you’ll notice from my reply to your first post). Any honest and rationally thinking person can see this.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, can't we have both?  :D

47410[/snapback]

 

Hmmmmm, we'll see Adam.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It looks like, from the silence here, that we aren't going to hear any of it Adam. :o

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It looks like, from the silence here, that we aren't going to hear any of it Adam.  :o

47469[/snapback]

It's just additional confirmation that atheists see the intellectual vacuum created by atheism, if not in profession, at least in practice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest martemius

Its fairly simple martemius, I made it that way on purpose.

We know we “areâ€ÂÂ! We know “from nothing, nothing comesâ€ÂÂ… SO:

AND

Also, remember... No equivocating!

47431[/snapback]

Yeah, still not too clear to me what you're going for. Maybe this thread isn't for me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's just additional confirmation that atheists see the intellectual vacuum created by atheism, if not in profession, at least in practice.

47477[/snapback]

No Doubt :o

 

The problem is, I made it crystal clear whilst at the same time yanking the equivocation curtain away so it couldn't be hid behind. Now the evo-wizards won't come and play :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No Doubt  :o

 

The problem is, I made it crystal clear whilst at the same time yanking the equivocation curtain away so it couldn't be hid behind. Now the evo-wizards won't come and play  :P

47488[/snapback]

This really isn't a big leap. Plenty of atheists understand what is going on here and even accept it, even if it is through gritted teeth. I guess it isn't as commonly understood on the popular level, putting many atheists into the awkward position of believing they can defend their atheism as an epistemological base. I guess the atheists who can articulate and understand this problem from their own perspective are still too hesitant to carry out the candor and effort to explain it to those that listen to them. I'm think of Richard Dawkins, Dan Dennett, Hitchens and Sam Harris for starters. All of these people will acknowledge the intellectual vacuum that is atheism, when pressed, at least. However, they seem to forget to explain these implications to their followers.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's just additional confirmation that atheists see the intellectual vacuum created by atheism, if not in profession, at least in practice.

47477[/snapback]

Silence is just silence Adam, not confirmation.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

And you wonder why more people aren't talking to you...

47496[/snapback]

That's my bad martemius, I apologize, I thought you were just being sarcastic.

 

 

But this does pose a bigger problem (though not for the theist, regardless of stripe); Are you actually saying that you don't understand my questioning the foundations of atheism? Because the thread is set up in such a way as to go to the heart of atheism, and it does so in a succinct and cogent manner. So now I have to ask why you don't understand it!

 

If that is the case, then you may be correct; maybe this thread isn't for you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest martemius

That's my bad martemius, I apologize, I thought you were just being sarcastic.

But this does pose a bigger problem (though not for the theist, regardless of stripe); Are you actually saying that you don't understand my questioning the foundations of atheism? Because the thread is set up in such a way as to go to the heart of atheism, and it does so in a succinct and cogent manner. So now I have to ask why you don't understand it!

 

If that is the case, then you may be correct; maybe this thread isn't for you.

47498[/snapback]

I just want to know which aspect of origins you're talking about -- or, moreover, which type of supposed "something from nothing" you're getting at -- whether you're talking of matter from nothing (big bang) or life from non-life (abiogenesis).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Silence is just silence Adam,  not confirmation.

47495[/snapback]

Agreed, for the most part, but I have noticed the silence as more about the foundations of atheism, or the lack thereof...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

From where did we come (what are our Origins)?

Atheism has nothing to say on this. How can it. The only tenant to follow to be an Atheist is to have no belief/to believe that there is no God(s).

 

After that its up to the individual Atheist to follow up on what-ever questions they decide to answer about life and the universe.

 

I like the answer 42 to any questions about life, universe, everything. ;) (if no one gets this reference I will die a little today)

 

 

What are the atheistic foundations to support the atheistic worldview and philosophy of our origins?

47396[/snapback]

 

42

 

but seriously I don't think you can form a philosophy on the origins with Atheism.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like the answer 42 to any questions about life, universe, everything. ;)

47506[/snapback]

42 is the answer to the Great Question of Life. The Universe and Everything :)

 

(sorry for nit picking)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

SO…. If, according to the atheist, we go to nothing when we die; from where did we come, to get here?

47396[/snapback]

I also had to re-post Ron's question now that the answer '42' has come into play. It's amazing how relevantly atheists believe they can speak to the truth of life and how 'truth' pertains to us religious folk. However, when examined closely the atheist exposes the philosophically empty reservoir from whence they judge other worldviews.

 

...but there is hope but it will require a shift to a new thread because the atheists here have passed a test, recognizing that atheism has no power for actually discerning truth (but '42' does ;) )

 

After that its up to the individual Atheist to follow up on what-ever questions they decide to answer about life and the universe.

47506[/snapback]

I have noticed a consistent trend among the secular people who rightly come to this conclusion as they acknowledge that atheism must be abandoned, as a belief system, and something else must fill this void (or remain intellectually lazy and pretend that there is no need... eat, drink and be merry, for tomorrow we die...). The trend is this; a sudden case of bashfulness and/or derisive diversion to avoid having to actually deal with the epistemological mess in their own philosophical closet. It seems that many atheists forget to put their own house in order because they are preoccupied with criticizing others.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sign in to follow this  

×

Important Information

Our Terms